Heretic sayings of the salaf

The term "heretic" is a strong and loaded term that is not typically used in the context of the Salaf (early generations of Muslims). However, there were some controversial or unorthodox sayings attributed to certain individuals among the Salaf. It is important to note that these sayings are not considered representative of mainstream Islamic beliefs and should be approached with caution. Some examples include:

1. The saying attributed to Ibn Abbas, a companion of the Prophet Muhammad, that "Allah created the creation for Muhammad, and He would not have created anything if it were not for him." This statement has been criticized by scholars for its extreme praise of the Prophet Muhammad.

2. The saying attributed to Hasan al-Basri, a prominent Tabi'i (successor of the companions), that "The Quran is created." This statement was part of the theological debates around the nature of the Quran and was considered controversial by mainstream scholars.

3. The saying attributed to Ma'bad al-Juhani, a theologian from the early Islamic period, that "The Quran is the speech of Allah, but it is not uncreated." This statement was also part of the theological debates and was considered deviant by mainstream scholars.

It is important to approach such sayings with caution and to seek guidance from knowledgeable scholars when encountering them. It is also important to remember that the vast majority of the sayings and teachings of the Salaf are in line with mainstream Islamic beliefs and practices.

Above is Heretic sayings of the salaf.